Research Review #3

Meditation, exercise, yoga, gratitude journaling. Which one should you bother with?

There's no shortage of advice about improving your mental and emotional well-being.

Meditate every morning. Practice gratitude. Do yoga. Spend more time outside. Exercise regularly. Learn to be kinder to yourself.

All perfectly reasonable suggestions.

But if you're already juggling work, family, relationships, household responsibilities, and the occasional existential crisis while standing in the grocery store, adding another daily obligation might not sound particularly appealing.

So which of these practices actually works best?

And does it matter which one you choose?

We've had research supporting most of these approaches for years. What's been missing is a good comparison between them.

A 2026 study published in Nature Human Behaviour attempted to answer that question by comparing 11 different types of well-being interventions.

The researchers found that nearly all of them helped.

They also discovered that combining physical activity with psychological practices might offer additional benefits, although the evidence isn't nearly as strong as the headlines might suggest.

And perhaps most importantly, their findings support something I've emphasized throughout my coaching career:

You don't necessarily need the perfect practice. You need something that improves your life and fits into the one you're already living.

Let's look at what they found.

How the Study Worked

Researchers collected 183 randomized controlled trials involving 22,811 adults.

A randomized controlled trial is a study where participants are randomly assigned to different groups. Some receive an intervention, while others serve as a comparison group.

In this case, researchers were interested in adults without diagnosed mental health conditions. They wanted to know which practices could improve general well-being, rather than specifically treat clinical depression, anxiety, or other disorders.

They examined 11 categories of interventions, including:

  • Mindfulness and meditation
  • Yoga
  • Physical exercise
  • Self-compassion practices
  • Exercise combined with psychological techniques
  • Acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT)
  • Positive psychology exercises, such as gratitude journaling
  • Educational programs about psychological well-being
  • Time in nature
  • Programs combining several psychological techniques

To compare everything, the researchers used something called a network meta-analysis.

Sounds complicated, but the concept is straightforward.

Imagine one study compares meditation with doing nothing different. Another compares yoga with doing nothing different. A third compares exercise with doing nothing different.

Even though meditation, yoga, and exercise weren't necessarily tested against one another, researchers can use their results against the comparison groups to estimate how they stack up.

That's essentially what a network meta-analysis does.

It's useful because it allows scientists to compare interventions across many studies. However, indirect comparisons come with uncertainty, especially when the underlying studies differ in quality.

And in this review, study quality turned out to be an important issue.

What the Researchers Found

Nearly every intervention improved well-being compared with a control group.

The researchers measured these improvements using something called a standardized mean difference, or SMD.

You don't need a statistics degree to understand the takeaway.

An SMD measures how much two groups differ, expressed in standardized units so researchers can compare results from studies using different questionnaires.

As a rough guide:

  • 0.2: Small effect
  • 0.5: Moderate effect
  • 0.8: Large effect

Larger positive numbers suggest greater improvements, although they don't tell us exactly how much happier an individual person will feel.

Here's how the different practices stacked up, ordered by their estimated effect sizes.

Well-being practice Effect size (SMD)
Exercise + psychological practice 0.73
Yoga 0.49
Self-compassion 0.45
Mindfulness 0.44
Exercise alone 0.42
Single positive psychology exercise 0.41
Mixed psychological programs 0.40
Acceptance and commitment therapy 0.39
Multiple positive psychology exercises 0.31
Psychoeducation 0.26
Time in nature 0.05

These are estimated improvements relative to control conditions, not proof that each practice outperformed the ones below it.

At first glance, exercise combined with psychological practices looks like the clear winner.

An effect size of 0.73 is substantially larger than the results for exercise or mindfulness alone.

Great! Case closed. Get yourself some running shoes and start reciting affirmations between sets.

Well, not quite.

The apparent winner had some pretty big limitations.

The exercise-plus-psychology category included just three studies involving approximately 106 people.

Those interventions involved walking combined with psychological techniques, including meditation, awe-focused walking, and group walks with positive psychology coaching.

Two of those three studies had a high risk of bias.

In other words, the results are promising, but we're working with a small amount of relatively shaky evidence.

Meanwhile, mindfulness had an estimated effect size of 0.44, supported by studies involving thousands of participants.

Its effect was smaller, but the evidence was more extensive and consistent.

That's an important distinction.

A larger estimated benefit doesn't automatically mean stronger scientific evidence.

The researchers also found no consistent statistically significant differences between most of the established psychological practices.

So while yoga scored 0.49 and mindfulness scored 0.44, we can't confidently claim yoga works better.

Those differences could simply reflect the uncertainty in the available research.

What about spending time in nature?

This was probably the biggest head-scratcher.

Time in nature produced an effect size of only 0.05, which wasn't significantly different from the control groups.

Does this mean your afternoon walk through the woods is worthless?

Of course not.

The nature-based studies were relatively small and tested quite different activities, ranging from gardening-related therapies to nature photography.

That's a pretty broad collection of experiences to squeeze into one category.

The evidence was too limited and inconsistent to draw strong conclusions about nature's effectiveness.

Besides, plenty of activities are worth doing because you enjoy them, regardless of whether they produce an impressive score on a psychological questionnaire.

Not every enjoyable experience needs a clinical trial to justify its existence.

Consistency and duration also mattered.

One interesting finding was that interventions lasting five to eight weeks generally produced better results than those lasting two to four weeks.

That's useful because people often try a new practice for a few days, notice nothing remarkable, and abandon it.

We've all done it.

But mental and emotional well-being practices often involve learning skills, creating habits, and developing new ways to respond to everyday experiences.

Those things can take practice.

That doesn't mean everyone needs exactly eight weeks or that longer is always better. But it suggests giving a reasonable practice enough time before deciding whether it's worthwhile.

Finally, the researchers identified substantial limitations across the literature.

Sixty percent of the included trials were classified as having a high risk of bias, and many didn't follow participants long enough to establish whether the benefits lasted.

The results are encouraging, but there's plenty left to learn.

Takeaways

1. Choose what fits your life, not whatever topped the rankings.

I've worked with hundreds of people who wanted to improve their stress management, sleep, recovery, and overall health.

One of the biggest lessons I've learned is that the best plan on paper isn't worth much if it doesn't work in practice.

Some people love meditation.

Others sit down, close their eyes, and spend ten minutes thinking about the laundry, the emails they haven't answered, and whether they're somehow meditating incorrectly.

For those people, a different approach might be more useful.

Someone who loves walking could try taking a quiet walk without their phone.

Someone who enjoys writing could spend five minutes reflecting on something they're grateful for, something they handled well, or something they're looking forward to.

Someone who enjoys movement and group activities might love yoga.

Someone who struggles with self-criticism could practice self-compassion by learning to respond to mistakes the way they would respond to a close friend.

And someone who regularly gets stuck fighting uncomfortable thoughts or feelings might benefit from ACT, an approach that teaches us to make room for difficult experiences while continuing to act according to our values.

None of these approaches requires you to become a completely different person.

They simply provide different ways to practice responding to life.

Here's a simple experiment:

Choose one practice you're genuinely interested in and try it consistently for four to eight weeks.

Start small enough that you're likely to follow through. Five or ten minutes might be plenty.

Then evaluate it.

Are you feeling calmer? Recovering from stressful experiences more easily? Sleeping better? Enjoying your days more? Responding to challenges with greater flexibility?

If so, keep going.

If not, adjust the practice or try something different.

The objective isn't to collect wellness habits like Pokémon cards.

It's to build a life you enjoy living.

2. Exercise belongs in the conversation about mental and emotional health.

This is one of my favorite findings from the review.

Exercise alone produced an effect size of 0.42, putting it right alongside mindfulness, self-compassion, and other established psychological practices.

And that was among adults without diagnosed mental health conditions.

Previous research has also found that physical activity can improve symptoms of depression and anxiety, with both aerobic exercise and resistance training showing benefits.

That doesn't mean exercise replaces therapy, medication, or professional mental health care.

It means physical activity can support our mental health in addition to improving strength, endurance, cardiovascular fitness, and physical functioning.

Think about the different ways movement can improve an ordinary day.

You step away from your desk.

Your attention shifts away from whatever has been irritating you.

You get outside, breathe some fresh air, or interact with other people.

You experience the satisfaction of doing something challenging.

Maybe you finish feeling more capable, less tense, or simply pleased that you did something good for yourself.

Those experiences count.

Your Tuesday strength-training session isn't only about building muscle. Your evening bike ride isn't only about burning calories.

Both might contribute to your emotional well-being, too.

And combining movement with psychological skills offers an interesting possibility.

Maybe you take a walk and intentionally notice the things around you rather than spending the entire time mentally rehearsing tomorrow's problems.

Maybe you reflect on something you're grateful for while cooling down after a workout.

Maybe you practice accepting uncomfortable thoughts during a challenging training session instead of immediately trying to eliminate them.

These aren't guaranteed improvements, and the research on combining approaches is still developing.

But they're practical ways to experiment without adding another hour of obligations to your schedule.

Sometimes the easiest way to build a new habit is to attach it to something you're already doing.

Closing Thoughts

I think there's a tendency in the health and wellness world to turn every useful practice into another responsibility.

You should meditate.

You should journal.

You should exercise.

You should practice gratitude.

You should spend more time outside.

Before long, improving your well-being starts looking suspiciously like another part-time job.

And that rather defeats the purpose.

This research suggests we have several promising ways to improve our mental and emotional well-being, with no convincing evidence that one established approach is universally superior.

That's good news.

It means you have options.

You can experiment, pay attention to how you respond, and choose practices that support your life rather than complicate it.

And if something isn't working, you can change course without feeling like you've failed some imaginary wellness exam.

After all, the whole point of taking better care of ourselves is to have more energy, freedom, and enjoyment for the people and experiences that matter to us.

Not to become professional practitioners of self-improvement.

Less stress, more life.


References

  1. Wilkie L, Fisher Z, Geidel A, Goodall I, Kamil S, Davies E, et al. A systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials of well-being-focused interventions. Nature Human Behaviour. 2026;10:715–726.
  2. Singh B, Olds T, Curtis R, Dumuid D, Virgara R, Watson A, et al. Effectiveness of physical activity interventions for improving depression, anxiety and distress: an overview of systematic reviews. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2023;57(18):1203–1209.
  3. Banyard H, Edward KL, Garvey L, Stephenson J, Azevedo L, Benson AC. The effects of aerobic and resistance exercise on depression and anxiety: Systematic review with meta-analysis. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing. 2025;34:e70054.