
I had two client check-ins recently that reminded me why I still love doing this after 15 years.
We talked about chicken sandwiches, running, lifting weights, walking dogs, maintenance calories, family responsibilities, and what to do when life gets in the way of our best intentions.
Pretty standard stuff.
But these two clients have been working with me for years, and looking at how they approach their health and fitness today compared to when we started is fascinating.
Both have developed four skills that I believe are essential to maintaining a healthy lifestyle: flexibility, consistency, learning, and long-term commitment.
These are skills I've spent 15 years refining in my own life and teaching to hundreds of clients.
And I've changed my mind about quite a few things along the way.
1. Flexibility: From Six Egg Whites to Having Your Shit Together
When I first learned nutrition coaching, I was incredibly rigid.
I wrote meal plans that prescribed exactly what someone would eat, how much, and when.
Breakfast at 7 a.m.? Two-thirds of a cup of oatmeal, six egg whites, three whole eggs, and half a tablespoon of peanut butter.
Lunch at noon? Another carefully measured collection of foods.
Dinner, snacks, supplements. Every detail accounted for.
Workouts were programmed with similar precision. Exercises, sets, repetitions, times, and schedules.
There was one track to success, and any deviation was treated as a lack of discipline or willpower.
I was very good at writing these plans.
Unfortunately, people have lives.
Once I started my own coaching business, I learned pretty quickly that hyper-programming everyone's nutrition and fitness wasn't sustainable.
People have jobs, children, relationships, responsibilities, injuries, and schedules that change without asking permission.
If my clients were going to practice healthy behaviors for the rest of their lives, we had to adopt flexibility.
One of the clients I recently checked in with is a father of two. Earlier in our relationship, we worked to rebuild his exercise habits around the arrival of his youngest child.
He eventually progressed to lifting regularly and running 5Ks.
In our latest check-in, he told me he hadn't completed a 5K in several weeks. He's been running two miles after lifting instead, whenever time permits.
No disappointment. No guilt. No elaborate explanation about why he couldn't complete the original workout.
He gets his lifting done and runs when he has the time.
My other client has been developing similar flexibility with her nutrition.
She's using approximately 21 days of calorie deficits and seven days of maintenance each month. Instead of following a rigid schedule, she can distribute those days based on what's happening in her life.
A dinner out, vacation, or unexpected social occasion doesn't require throwing away the entire plan.
Both handle these situations like adults who have their shit together.
They're navigating their work, families, and responsibilities while continuing to practice the behaviors we've established.
They can admit to having a less-than-perfect month without guilt or shame.
That's a substantial change from where we started.
But there's a limit to flexibility.
At a certain point, you could flex your way right into sedentism, overeating, and an undisciplined mess.
That's why we establish minimum effective doses that are non-negotiable under normal circumstances.
Every important practice has a measurement.
For one client, that might mean 7,500 steps daily, a minimum amount of weekly resistance training, and established calorie and macro targets.
Those prescriptions are individualized. They also change when health, recovery, or circumstances genuinely require it.
The minimums give us a foundation. Everything above them can be adjusted according to someone's goals, abilities, and available resources.
Flexibility works because we know which things can move and which things need to remain in place.
2. Consistency: Perfection Is a Pretty Useless Standard
After 15 years of coaching, consistency means returning to the minimums we've established regardless of ordinary changes in feeling or mood.
We measure it.
How many workouts did you complete? How many steps did you take? How much sleep did you get? How closely did your nutrition match the plan?
Then we use that information to make adjustments.
The default for everyone is imperfection.
I can count on one hand how many perfect months I've seen in 15 years of coaching.
Seriously.
Once someone learns how to live this lifestyle, perfection becomes an almost useless standard.
My client who's been running and lifting has also developed an incredibly simple nutrition system.
On Mondays, he bulk-cooks chicken breasts. He keeps steamable rice available and makes sandwiches using sliced chicken. He incorporates fruit, cereal, and other convenient foods to meet his calorie and macro targets.
Nothing complicated.
No culinary gymnastics. No Sunday afternoon spent preparing seventeen containers of food that will taste like refrigerated disappointment by Wednesday.
He found inexpensive, convenient foods he enjoys and made them repeatable.
My other client has a Tonal system at home and genuinely enjoys using it. She's getting approximately 7,500 steps daily, often walking outside with her dogs, and has established Sundays as her recovery day.
She likes having her own exercise space downstairs. She's feeling stronger, her clothes are fitting better, and she's enjoying the process.
What impresses me about both clients is that they continue showing up.
They continue checking in, communicating, and practicing.
They also make deliberate choices about how they live and eat, even when those choices differ from the habits of the people around them.
That requires commitment.
When someone struggles with consistency, my first job is to figure out what's getting in the way.
We lay everything out and look for the bottleneck.
Is it time? Energy? Sleep? Food preparation? An unrealistic training schedule? A calorie target that isn't appropriate anymore?
Once we identify the problem, we go to work on it.
Usually, the solution involves small actions repeated until they become habits, continued accountability, and adjusting the plan based on what actually happens.
It's rarely glamorous.
But after enough repetition, people become capable of maintaining these practices through circumstances that once would have derailed them.
3. Learning: I Can Lead a Horse to Water
One of the things I most want clients to understand is that sleep, food, and movement form the foundations of human health.
We have meaningful influence over all three through our daily behaviors, even though we can't control every outcome or circumstance.
Behaviorism leads.
I want clients thinking about sustainability before anything else. Then we use the best tools available, including calorie and macro tracking, activity measurements, performance data, and their own feedback, to make evidence-based decisions.
In other words, we use the scientific method.
Establish a plan. Practice it. Collect information. Evaluate what happened. Adjust.
One of my recent clients demonstrated how valuable that education can become outside our coaching relationship.
A family member was recovering in a clinical setting and receiving what appeared to be inadequate nutrition support, particularly protein.
My client recognized the issue.
He and his mother intervened, helping their loved one increase protein intake with a convenient supplement. They reported a positive outcome.
Medical nutrition during recovery requires individual assessment, and we can't attribute that outcome to a single intervention.
Still, I was impressed.
He recognized a potential nutritional problem, understood why it mattered, and used what he'd learned to help someone he loved.
We also discussed his own maintenance calories.
He'd lost weight during a week when we intended for him to maintain.
That's useful information. It could mean his actual energy requirements are higher than our current prescription, although short-term weight fluctuations can contribute, too.
We look at his food records, activity, weight trends, and feedback before deciding what to change.
My other client has learned how to use a nutrition strategy she's practiced successfully before.
After a month that included vacations and plenty of eating out, she returned to her established schedule of deficit and maintenance days.
She's becoming more comfortable distributing calories across the month and making informed decisions without turning every unexpected meal into a crisis.
These are the outcomes I want from coaching.
I still take responsibility for the technical prescriptions. That's my job.
But I'm trained in several coaching approaches, and I've learned that asking questions is often more effective than simply providing answers.
I generally know what I want clients to learn. The challenge is helping them work through the problem and arrive at an understanding they can use again.
You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink.
You can, however, teach him where the water is, how to recognize it, and why he might want to drink it.
Hopefully without writing him a six-page hydration protocol.
4. Long-Term Progress: Learning How Much Is Enough
What separates someone who makes progress for a few months from someone who continues progressing for years?
Commitment.
Plain and simple.
Are they committed to the process?
If so, we can progress this stuff for life.
If not, there are plenty of yo-yo programs and new hype shit hitting the market every year, ready to take your money and leave you right where you started.
Commitment doesn't mean refusing to change the plan. The clients who sustain their progress tend to recognize when change is necessary and keep practicing through it.
Consider how far my two clients have come.
One went from struggling to fit exercise around fatherhood to regularly lifting and running 5Ks. At one point, he was completing multiple 5Ks every week.
Today, he's comfortable running shorter distances when his schedule requires it.
He's learned how to feed himself consistently, adjust his maintenance intake, and use nutritional knowledge beyond his own goals.
The other has moved away from the extremes of perfect adherence followed by periods of falling out of practice.
She's returned to a successful nutrition strategy, enjoys her workouts, walks regularly, and is seeing improvements in strength and how her clothes fit.
She's particularly proud that she didn't wait until January to start taking better care of herself.
Neither has eliminated the challenges of everyday life.
They've developed better ways to handle them.
And this brings me to one of the hardest lessons I've had to learn as a coach.
Teaching people how much is enough, in a culture that always demands more.
I had to learn this in my own life before I became particularly good at coaching it.
Early in someone's fitness experience, they often want a bigger bench press, a lower body fat percentage, or a faster running time.
Those are perfectly reasonable goals.
But on a long enough timeline, I see clients increasingly shift toward something else.
They want longevity.
They want to remain strong, capable, active, independent, and healthy as they age.
And the practices that support those outcomes don't necessarily resemble what the modern fitness industry likes to advertise.
Extremism reigns supreme.
Everything needs to be harder, heavier, faster, leaner, or more optimized than whatever you were doing last week.
Meanwhile, the physical activity guidelines recommend a much more achievable foundation for adults: at least 150 minutes of moderate aerobic activity weekly, along with muscle-strengthening exercise on two or more days.
Those guidelines aren't a ceiling, and individuals can benefit from doing more. But they illustrate how much health can be supported by a consistent, manageable practice.
Nutrition works similarly. We establish appropriate calories, protein, carbohydrate and fat ranges, fiber, produce, and other useful habits based on someone's needs.
Sleep and recovery have their own requirements.
Then we practice.
Minimum doses over long periods of time seem too boring, too simple, and not ambitious enough.
But I don't care to argue about it anymore.
The evidence supporting regular physical activity, adequate sleep, and good nutrition is overwhelming.
Once we've established how much is enough to support someone's goals, teaching them to live within those practices becomes the next challenge.
It's liberating.
It's challenging.
And it's worth it.
Three Old-School Thanksgiving Strategies I've Taught for Over a Decade
Thanksgiving is a useful opportunity to put everything we've discussed into practice.
For more than a decade, I've taught clients three strategies for accommodating larger holiday meals.
They're practical tools. They also provide a pretty entertaining look at how my own coaching has evolved.
1. Banking Calories and Macros
This is probably the most widely used of the three.
The principle is straightforward.
Instead of treating every day's calorie target as an isolated event, we can move some of our intake around the calendar.
For example, someone might reduce their intake by 250 calories for four days leading up to Thanksgiving.
That creates an additional 1,000 calories they can allocate to the holiday meal while keeping their total intake across those five days unchanged.
Some clients prefer larger adjustments, sometimes 500–750 calories daily, although those reductions aren't appropriate for everyone. We consider their starting intake, nutritional needs, hunger, and training before deciding whether that makes sense.
The banking can happen before or after the occasion, depending on preference.
Protein stays consistent. We make the calorie adjustments primarily through carbohydrate and fat intake.
I've had clients use this strategy successfully for years.
They bank calories for Thanksgiving, Christmas, birthdays, vacations, and other food-centered occasions.
It's especially useful for people who enjoy tracking their macros and prefer making deliberate adjustments.
The goal is to accommodate food they want to enjoy while maintaining a reasonable overall energy intake.
If banking makes you miserable, constantly hungry, or preoccupied with compensating for every bite, we have other options.
2. Depletion Workouts: The Stairway to Heaven
Years ago, when I was doing more small-group and personal training, we had a workout called the Stairway to Heaven.
It was a two-hour workout from hell.
The centerpiece was a squat pyramid.
One squat. Then two. Then three.
All the way to 25, and back down to one.
That's 625 squats.
Because apparently there was a time in my life when I thought the proper way to prepare for Thanksgiving was to punish everyone's quadriceps before sunrise.
These workouts became rituals.
Insanely loud music, gym barbarism, and start times before 6 a.m.
They served a similar social purpose to a Turkey Trot or a CrossFit hero workout. People gathered, challenged themselves, and shared an experience.
There was also a nutritional rationale.
We wanted to increase energy expenditure and use some stored muscle glycogen before consuming a larger meal.
Exercise does use energy, and resistance training can deplete glycogen. But the amount depends on the workout, and we can't assume a hard session cancels out a specific number of Thanksgiving calories.
My thinking about these workouts has changed dramatically.
Today, if someone wants to include extra movement around Thanksgiving, I might suggest a workout on the morning of the holiday or the following day that's approximately 50% longer than their usual session, provided their conditioning and recovery can comfortably support it.
For someone accustomed to a 30-minute walk, that might mean 45 minutes.
For someone who regularly trains for an hour, we can consider whether a longer session makes sense.
The purpose is to create some additional activity and energy expenditure around a higher-intake occasion.
A normal workout is also perfectly fine.
We've retired the requirement to perform hundreds of squats while some lunatic turns the gym speakers up to eleven.
I've mellowed with age.
A little.
3. Fasting
The third strategy is fasting.
Historically, I've taught it pretty simply.
Know when you're going to eat your larger meal, count backward 18–24 hours, and stop eating at that point.
You can also place the fasting period after the occasion.
This approach tends to appeal to people who regularly go longer stretches without eating and don't find the experience particularly uncomfortable.
But the subjective experience matters tremendously.
Some people can comfortably go most of the day without food. Others become irritable, distracted, lightheaded, or excessively hungry.
A longer fast can also make it more difficult to meet protein and other nutritional needs.
The research doesn't suggest fasting has some universal weight-loss advantage over comparable calorie restriction. A 2025 systematic review of 99 randomized trials found broadly similar weight-loss results between intermittent fasting and conventional energy restriction, with some differences between specific fasting approaches.
An 18–24-hour fast also isn't appropriate for everyone. People with a history of disordered eating, those who are pregnant or breastfeeding, and people with diabetes or medications affected by food intake need particular caution and, where appropriate, medical guidance.
I wouldn't recommend that someone experiment with a prolonged fast for the first time just because Thanksgiving is approaching.
From a sustainability standpoint, fasting is preference-based.
It's something we can use when it's appropriate and useful.
We don't have to endure it for long-term health.
So, Which Strategy Should You Use?
Maybe banking calories sounds appealing.
Maybe you'd enjoy a longer workout or a Thanksgiving morning walk.
Maybe you're already comfortable with fasting and prefer to organize your eating that way.
Or maybe you'd rather eat your regular breakfast, enjoy Thanksgiving dinner, have some leftovers, and return to your usual routine afterward.
That's a perfectly reasonable option, too.
One holiday meal doesn't require a nutritional intervention.
And that's where all four of the skills we've discussed come together.
Flexibility allows you to adjust the plan.
Consistency gives you something reliable to return to.
Learning helps you understand the available options and make informed decisions.
Long-term commitment keeps the entire process moving forward, even when life gets messy.
After 15 years of coaching, I care much more about whether someone can sustain their practices for years than whether they can execute a flawless Thanksgiving nutrition strategy.
I used to think success required an incredibly precise prescription.
Now I spend much of my time helping people understand how much is enough, establish the practices that support it, and make room for the rest of their lives.
That's a considerably better use of everyone's time.
And it involves far fewer 625-squat workouts.
Happy Thanksgiving.
Less stress, more life.